Security Training

Compare

Compare security training and exercise platforms side by side

Field note

Pick two to five platforms to compare every criterion score and reason, published pricing and format. The default view shows the top three on our weights: Reflex Security (7.7 of 10), Immersive Labs (7.6) and iluminr (7.5). Every pair also has its own head-to-head page below.

Editorial assessment · Assessed from vendor sites, product pages and published pricing, September 2026

M-1Choose platforms

 

M-2Side-by-side scores

Readiness score by criterion (editorial assessment, 0–10), with the reason for each score.
CriterionReflex SecurityTop pick for replacing the annual tabletopRanked 1 of 9Immersive LabsTop pick for one platform across every audienceRanked 2 of 9iluminrTop pick for board and regulator evidenceRanked 3 of 9
Weighted score
7.7
Highest
7.6
7.5
Realism (25%)
9
Highest

Builds the scenario from the organization's public footprint, can add its telemetry, and runs an unscripted AI adversary that reacts to each decision.

8

Crisis simulations with dynamic injects and AI actors players can question, built around the customer's playbooks; a separate range runs live attacks on the customer's own tools.

7

Real-time injects and immersive media; AI assesses each response against the organization's own plans.

Cross-team (25%)
9
Tie

Designed to put technical, legal and executive teams in one exercise; AI agents fill seats for absent roles, including the CEO.

8

Crisis Sim targets executives, incident leaders and cross-functional teams; Cyber Drills exercise technical and business teams together.

9
Tie

Built for boards, executives, crisis teams and risk functions, from single-player microsimulations to multiplayer team drills.

Evidence (20%)
8

After-action report generated at the end, each finding traced to the moment it came from, mapped to SOC 2, ISO 27001 and DORA. Less board benchmarking than iluminr.

8

Decision-level measurement, a Resilience Score, benchmarks across teams and cohorts, and evidence against frameworks such as NIS2 and DORA.

9
Highest

Board-ready dashboards, benchmarking by department, region and role, and evidence trails for DORA, APRA CPS 230, ISO 22301, NIST CSF and other frameworks.

Effort to run (15%)
9
Highest

Scenario in minutes, a sixty-minute session, and an AI facilitator that joins Zoom, Meet or Teams; asynchronous play is supported.

7

AI Program Builder drafts scenarios in minutes, but a multi-product platform needs more program ownership than a single-purpose tool.

8

3–5 minute individual microsimulations and 30–45 minute team exercises make frequent practice practical.

Hands-on depth (5%)
2

No labs or live-fire range. Technical staff make decisions in the exercise; they do not do keyboard work.

9
Highest

Browser labs against live systems across AI, application, cloud, OT and offensive security; Dynamic Threat Range uses tools such as Sentinel, Elastic, Splunk and CrowdStrike.

2

Operational and business resilience exercising; no technical hands-on work.

Breadth and free access (5%)
2

A scenario generator rather than a content library, with no free tier or community.

9
Highest

Labs, drills, ranges and crisis simulations for audiences from non-technical staff to SOC analysts and executives.

6

Covers cyber and non-cyber disruption across many sectors; no free tier.

Pricing (5%)
1
Tie

No price published; access is through a demo.

1
Tie

No price published.

1
Tie

No price published.

FormatsTabletop and crisis simulationTabletop and crisis simulation, Live-fire range, Hands-on labsTabletop and crisis simulation
AudiencesExecutives and board, Incident response teamExecutives and board, Incident response team, SOC analysts, Whole companyExecutives and board, Incident response team, Whole company
How it is deliveredAI facilitator inside Zoom, Meet or Teams; asynchronous play supportedBrowser-based platform (Immersive One)Microsimulations, team exercises and facilitated tabletops
Free accessNo free tierNot publishedNo free tier
Published priceNot publishedNot published, contact sales. Access is through a demo.Not publishedNot published, contact sales.Not publishedNot published, contact sales.

Want a different weighting? Use the calculator.

Immersive Labs vs Reflex Security · iluminr vs Reflex Security · iluminr vs Immersive Labs

M-3Every head-to-head

M-4Alternatives pages

M-5Frequently asked questions

Which security training platform scores highest overall?

Reflex Security scores highest on our weights at 7.7 of 10, followed by Immersive Labs (7.6) and iluminr (7.5). The totals reward a response-team brief; the per-criterion rows show who fits a different one.

How many platforms can I compare at once?

Two to five. The selection is saved in the page address, so you can share or bookmark a comparison.

Why is KnowBe4 not in the comparison?

KnowBe4 sells security awareness training, a different category, so it is reviewed but not scored. See the KnowBe4 review.